When Progress Breaks Identity: The No True Scotsman Problem in AI

by Nat Currier 19 min read
AITechnologyLeadershipBusiness Strategy
When Progress Breaks Identity: The No True Scotsman Problem in AI
Excerpt

Many AI arguments that look technical are really identity and status defenses. When capability shifts threaten labor value, communities redefine what counts as real expertise, intelligence, or innovation.

Cite This

Nat Currier. "When Progress Breaks Identity: The No True Scotsman Problem in AI." nat.io, 2026-02-25. https://nat.io/blog/no-true-scotsman-ai-identity

AI debates often look technical but behave like identity defense. A systems-oriented analysis of goalpost shifting, labor value anxiety, and organizational adaptation.

https://nat.io/blog/no-true-scotsman-ai-identity

Share link (tracked): https://nat.io/blog/no-true-scotsman-ai-identity?utm_source=citation&utm_medium=referral&utm_campaign=blog_cite

Key stat: 19 minute read

Work with me

I occasionally partner with founders, executives, and technical leaders who need to articulate complex ideas clearly and build real authority through long-form writing.

If you're trying to express something important and not satisfied with generic content, you can reach out here.